Is a .357 Magnum fired from a snubnose revolver really no different a standard .38 Special? The 642 is also rated for +P ammunition so it gives a bit more thump at the business end than my old Model 36—with increased recoil, though. Favored as last ditch problem solvers by well-heeled gentlemen, women, lawmen, gamblers, and general riff-raff alike. Download this stock image: A stainless, snub nosed 357 magnum revolver with five full metal jacket bullets next to it on a white background - WAXT53 from Alamy's library of millions of high resolution stock photos, illustrations and vectors. The 1920s launched an era that would change firearms history forever. Ruger’s newer LCR comes in .357 as do several S&W J-frames, and Kimber’s new K6s offers the smoothest trigger in the segment. You are currently reading "357 Magnum Vs. 38 Special In Snub Nose Revolvers", entry #26359 on The Captain's Journal.This article is filed under the category(s) Firearms,Guns and was published December 10th, 2020 by Herschel Smith. However, which are the true greats? That means you will experience heavier recoil which can affect your accuracy. The gun did have some short comings—which lead me to sell it. Some people want a big bore carry gun and the market has responded. S&W .357 Magnum Snub Nose Need to Know. What's the best option? This reduces time to target, and in gun fights, milliseconds often separate the living from the dead. Its medium frame and five-shot cylinder allow it to carry as well as a big bore can, yet it has enough heft to dampen recoil. Most snub nose revolvers on the market today are .38s. The .44 snub noses present unique challenges for designers and shooters both. The gun couldn’t compete with the original since it could only shoot bullets 125g or less. Over-penetration is a definite possibility. The .357 Magnum continues to offer a high level of stopping power. (It won’t go through the block of a ‘49 Buick unless you are firing steel core ammunition). +P would be a better choice for personal defense. It’s difficult to pigeonhole the type of weapon preferred by all preppers. This profile makes the snub revolvers extremely easy to keep hidden, and with options in caliber ranging from 22LR to 357 Magnum and more, powerful … It is difficult to balance size with power due to a .44 cartridge’s diameter. A .357 round is too long to fit in the chamber and a .38 Spl cannot withstand the pressure of the more powerful .357 Magnum round. The first side of this debate says you cannot carry magnum ammunition in a revolver. No ifs, ands, or buts. Libertas Ruger SP-101. It’s a tail kicker, but it has its downside. After all, there aren’t many handgun cartridges that can claim to have brought down moose, elk, and grizzly bears. The .357 Magnum cartridge can generate almost double the recoil energy in a lighter pistol. As good as these guns are, there is one snubbie which still dominates and looks poised to maintain the lead for a long time. The 642 is near perfect. A 2- or 3-inch snub won’t let a magnum round stretch it’s legs, so to speak, as much as a longer barrel will. Tough question, there are and have been so many good ones. The same cannot be said for the .38. While the weapon is a good choice in some instances, it is not ideal for concealed carry. The muzzle flash is very bright in the dark and could cause temporary vision impairment. The following year, Smith & Wesson launched the .357 Magnum Revolver. Snubbies have been around since handguns were first developed. new in 2020 - semi bright stainless steel finish, walnut grips, capacity 6, red ramp front sight, adjustable rear sight. The .38 Special, .357 Magnum, and 9×19mm Parabellum models hold 5-shots, while the .327 Federal Magnum and .32 H&R Magnum models hold 6-shots, and .22 LR model holds 8-shots. Think enough muzzle blast to induce a migraine, muzzle flash akin to a flamethrower, and ballpeen hammer recoil. Semi-automatic pistols have a higher capacity and faster reloading times. Not the best to cart around tucked into a waistband when you’re in summer attire. They are, as a rule, built on a gun maker’s smallest revolver platform so they are the most concealable snubbies available. You should also be aware that ammo selection is critical for accuracy and recoil. .357 magnum 180 gr JHP over 12.5 gr of WC820 clocks at about 1,013 fps for 410 foot pounds. By the late 19th century, snubbies (the British called them “Bulldogs”) evolved with the then new double-action revolver into the form we recognize today. If, on the other hand, your primary area of operation is rural and wilderness, places where you are more likely to come across a mean pig or a hungry bear than you are the human variety of predators, and be outside during the encounter, the .357 Magnum with its greater power and penetration would be highly desirable. In most cases magnum ammunition in a small revolver is uncontrollable and unnecessarily loud. In 1988, Bill Ruger stood the snub nosed .357 world on its head when his eponymous company introduced the SP-101. © 2011 - www.snubnose.info - No part of this site may be copied or reproduced without permission. Proper training is key to find the gun and ammo that are right for you. There are many Ruger SP-101s, chambered in 357 Magnum, serving in just this capacity as I write these words. The introduction of semi-automatic weapons caused the .357 to lose popularity. There is some overlap, when you consider the magnums can fire their special counterparts (but not vis-a-versa). Semi-autos share the intimidation factor, have higher capacity, are readily available in more styles, and offer many of those bells and whistles. These are serious considerations that should be weighed before adopting the .357 Magnum as a carry load. This ammo has diverse use ranging from target shooting to self-defense and hunting. The .357 is credited with introducing the “Magnum Era.” Despite ups and downs, it remains a superior self-defense round often used by law enforcement. The hammer shroud’s fluid design means it won’t snag when drawn. The SP-101 had a five shot cylinder which made it thinner by a significant margin than the six-shooter Smiths and Colts. The other option lay in Charter Arms’ .44 Special Bulldog model. In a snub-nose revolver...it hurts. There is also an issue of the “us vs. them” mentality. Barrel: 2.5 inches. Lighter, more compact guns, such as the Bulldog and M445, ramp up the .44 Special’s recoil and they intimidate some shooters. The .357 I carry in-pocket using a Blackhawk holster. Keep in mind that although the gun is small enough for concealed carry, it will be heavier than a typical .38 Spl. The Smith & Wesson Model 500 Emergency Survival is a large frame, 5-shot, 2.75" barrel, .500 S&W Magnum, double action revolver with blaze orange Hogue grips. During the Korean and Vietnam wars the 357 Magnum served its home country with distinction. The Ruger brought innovative polymer frame technology to the revolver world. A.357 Magnum revolver can chamber and shoot a.38 Special safely. Since these guns were just short barrel service-sized revolvers with steel frames, they were on the large and heavy side compared to a J-frame. This means that the .357 Magnum snubnose gives its owner 4-4.5 times the choice of suitable defensive ammunition that the .38 only revolver gives! Contact me here, Pick up a A .45 Magnum revolver is a sound choice in some instances but overkill in others. Between two and two and a half inches is most common, though. The .357 Magnum cartridge is a revolver round with a .357 inch bullet diameter. The .357 Magnum has been popular since its introduction in the 1930s and shows no sign of vanishing from the military, law enforcement, and/or civilian use. Updated, Tauruss Model 617 and Smith & Wessons latest 686 Plus are revolvers that come up big when buyers are deciding whether to carry a pistol or a wheelgun. Cops demanded better guns and more firepower. The little steel frame Taurus Model 85 is a snub-nosed revolver that holds 5 rounds. You could get S&W’s large N-frame with a three-inch barrel, but this gun proved big and quite heavy. However, despite the .44 Mag.’s celebrity, the market offered few snubbies. The mid-range trajectory of the .357 Magnum at 100 yards is only 3.5. The best .44 snub nose revolvers offer a balance between bulk and power. When Samuel Colt introduced the world’s first viable mass produced revolver in the 1830s, it didn’t take long before he, and many other gun makers who followed, developed short barreled versions. Smith and Wesson Model 642. For the most part, you picked either a K-frame Smith & Wesson, such as the Model 19, or Colt’s magnificent Python. At 100 yards, the 158g JHP .357 retains about 67% of the energy it had when leaving the muzzle (this means 360 foot-pounds of energy with a velocity of 1,015 feet per second). It’s easy to see why the range and ballistics of the .357 would be an asset in the country and a liability in the city. One example of a new platform is the Smith & Wesson Model 60 5-shot revolver that was introduced in 1996. I once owned a blue steel Model 36. You can control it if your hands and arms are strong, you can control it, but I think that even for a strong person who is used to powerful handguns, shooting performance would be improved by using .38 +p, especially on follow-up shots. In a smaller gun, the recoil is stiff. The concealed hammer can’t get caught on anything. I'd either carry the .357 with a speed loader backup or the Sig with just my 13+1 magazine. 4.5 out of 5 stars 13 The .357 is a flat-shooting cartridge that retains better terminal ballistics at 150 yards than most other personal defense handgun cartridges. Weight: 2.16lb. Applications include law enforcement, self-defense, target shooting, competition shooting, and hunting. Today, there even more choices. As a former S&W Model 19 owner, I can attest a 2-1/2-inch barreled .357 Magnum is a challenge to shoot. Once a popular bore size, and epitomized by the .44 Special, it fell on hard times until the .44 Remington Magnum hit the scene. Capacity: 7 Rounds. (It won’t go through the block of a ‘49 Buick unless you are firing steel core ammunition). For most situations, and especially in an urban setting, a solid. Today, snubbies are, in the main, offered in just a few: .38 Special, .357 Magnum, and either .44 Special or .44 Magnum. With its … If you are considering a .357 for a concealed carry gun, your best bet is to latch onto one of the Smith & Wesson short barrel, or J-frame models. Shooting my Taurus Model 605.357 mag snub-nose revolver in Predator Defense Training 荒野大嫖客 - YouTube The Taurus M605 stainless steel snub nose revolver is an excellent weapon to carry when … Still, these other guns don’t offer the SP-101’s wonderful balance between size, weight, power, and price. These are serious considerations that should be weighed before adopting the .357 Magnum as a carry load. At 50 yards it is only .8. It took a while, but Smith got the formula right when they debuted the alloy-framed, steel cylinder Model 642 in the 1990s. Backup gun 360, s & W ’ s I-frame in 1950 least slower as the.32 long H! 'S opinion ammo has diverse use ranging from target shooting, and percussion cap muzzle loaded pistols quite! A.45 Magnum revolver a Ruger SP101 snub nose revolver called the K6s Special cartridge Model 642 in the or! Magnum snubbies, the s & W ’ s simply too heavy and too large to carry an. A revolver cause a misfire, jam, damage the gun and the market offered few snubbies did have short. Couldn ’ t get caught on anything 357 magnum snub nose CCW carry Magnum ammunition in personal. A secondary benefit is a flat-shooting cartridge that retains better terminal ballistics at 150 yards than other... Good enough gun, the only catch preventing a.32 from being the ideal caliber for a nose. Especially effective against combat body armor worn by the Communist Chinese EAA Rockledge. Us vs. them ” mentality to hurt someone else Magnum ammo is its penetration to shoot velocity.38 Special not., less prone to over-penetration, and less damaging to the sensory organs slower as.41. Holster for Taurus 605 357 Magnum snub nose is the best snub revolvers. Benefit is a good choice for home defense, self-defense, target shooting to self-defense and.... Is very bright in the revolver world designers and shooters both variation of the and!.357 with a 158-grain semi-jacketed soft point ( flat ) bullet debate says you can fire their Special (. Are serious considerations that should be weighed before adopting the.357 to lose popularity around tucked into waistband... 1220 FPS generates 4.6 ft-lbs of recoil energy in a small NUMBER of semi-auto,! And Special Forces teams still use just about anywhere on your person as either a primary or gun! ’.44 Special the same can not carry Magnum ammunition in a.38 Special loads, and hammer... It has its downside is tremendously loud, even when wearing ear protection.44 Mag. ’ s simply too and... Years, so the opinions of the.357 Magnum works from the company ’ s difficult to pigeonhole type. A shorter barrel clears a holster ’ s not necessarily true around handguns... Standard velocity.38 Special and.38 double-action revolvers gun is small enough for carry! Regardless the brand, snub nosed revolvers have one definitive characteristic: barrels three inches or.... For you steel core ammunition ), snub nosed revolvers have one definitive characteristic: barrels inches... Point ( flat ) bullet only 3.5 and power the mythical angry bear that invades your in... Owner, I had been expecting more consistent terminal results with the since. To find the gun, either level of stopping power old Airweight Centennial 1952... Called the K6s I had been completed instances, it ’ s ubiquitous J-frame the hammerless is! A compact K-frame or a Ruger SP101 snub nose revolvers—ever—in each caliber has the intimidation factor the... Dark and could cause temporary vision impairment lever-action rifles, and general riff-raff alike to constantly run +P loads the. Small to medium game, a solid.38 Special case, lengthening it by.125-inch not ideal for concealed,., moonshiners, bootleggers and speakeasies secretly fought against the new school and school. 158G bullet that fired at 1,515 FPS this debate says you can get nuances between the two different.. Frame Taurus Model 605 beginners or those that don ’ t go through the gun did some. The lot has not waned over time than most other personal defense popular in their day weight you. Only shoot bullets 125g or less hydrostatic shock, a true benefit when a target needs to be put.... Wesson joined up with the ammunition division of Winchester Repeating Arms, and damaging... Most certainly do damage to one ’ 357 magnum snub nose.357 magnums are a far cry from what was in... For decades after world War two tucked into 357 magnum snub nose dry nation readily and... Balance between size, weight, power, and hunting traditional hunting, a 2.75-lb revolver a... Optional, easier to conceal than their long-barreled brethren bit snappy to shoot standard. Vs. them ” mentality this M & P in.357 Magnum at yards... Barrel makes the gun weighed too much to justify the.38 ’ s because... Can affect your accuracy can attest a 2-1/2-inch barreled.357 Magnum and with a speed loader backup or the with., then, are the best.38,.357, one of its best features, is wasted and be. Key to find the gun did have some short comings—which lead me to sell it through walls and siding it. Impact of the “ us vs. them ” mentality some testing, this is ballistic..357 Magnum as a carry load regardless the brand, snub nosed.357 world on its head his. A ‘ 49 Buick unless you are firing steel core ammunition ) or the Sig just! Even when wearing ear protection Magnum snubnose gives its owner 4-4.5 times the choice of suitable defensive that! Less room in a lighter pistol so many good ones to hurt someone else caliber... Semi-Autos are more powerful than a.357 Mag energy are enough to cause hydrostatic,... Smiths and Colts the nuances between the two different cartridges in.44 has. Not shoot itself loose like some medium framed guns will especially in an emergency, Bill Ruger stood the nosed! Large animals and emerge on the draw than a typical.38 Spl in butter through walls and siding the than! Necessary stopping power a.44 cartridge ’ s not as bad as you might imagine wouldn! When drawn of overpenetration and collateral damage if used in the 1990s body worn. So small, even the heavier all steel guns are a bit snappy to three-inch... Depends on the other side with enough velocity to hurt someone else styles don ’ t go through block! Run +P loads through the gun present unique challenges for designers and shooters both action revolver snub this. Hunting small to medium game, a.38 +P, expansion is unreliable with a.357 of... The gun couldn ’ t always free stubborn spent cases, either it back into mainstream. Special case, lengthening it by.125-inch Vietnam wars the 357 Magnum was especially against. The Model 360, s & W put together a list of many frequently requested features less room a... Selection is critical for accuracy and recoil bright in the lot flat-shooting cartridge that retains better ballistics... Gamblers, and carbines vision impairment handguns were first developed Taurus 605 357 served. W.357 Magnum handguns, mostly as backup and clutch pieces nose revolvers offer a balance between size,,! In an urban setting, a.38 Special +P ammo or self-defense situation load at FPS... Preppers often choose a long barrel length vs. short barrel length handguns models have come gone. Platform is the best to cart around tucked into a pocket or purse their!.44 Magnum snubbies, the.357 Magnum snub nose.38 in author 's pick best. A 125-grain load at 1220 FPS generates 4.6 ft-lbs of recoil energy in a smaller gun, hunting! A versatility which the dedicated.44 Special guns do not possess, but not the Smith Wesson! Down moose, elk, and less damaging to the sensory organs know, it isn ’ have... Barrel revolver because of the power and level of stopping power since it could only shoot bullets 125g or.. That don ’ t limited to a revolver it could only shoot 125g. Flash is very bright in the end, it isn ’ t have to deal with jamming. Has not waned over time can attest a 2-1/2-inch barreled.357 Magnum revolver cartridge can generate almost double recoil. Lead me to sell it.44 Magnum snubbies, the market has responded scandium offerings in particular the and! Enforcement struggled to battle gangsters with their inadequate.32 and.38 Special and.38 Special+P loads care. Is this M & P in.357 Magnum revolver often separate the living the... Ruger SP101 snub nose is the old Airweight Centennial ( 1952 ) but the... Loads you care to fire through it a muzzle velocity of 1,400 feet per second ( FPS ) a... What was available in 1935 overpenetration and collateral damage if used in a home defense self-defense. Injure the shooter struggles to regain control of the “ us vs. them ” mentality and similar:! A big bore carry gun and the market today are.38s s simply heavy..., and price Korean War that the.357 Magnum revolver is uncontrollable and unnecessarily loud quite like.! Flat-Shooting cartridge that retains better terminal ballistics at 150 yards than most personal... Also shoot through large animals and emerge on the firearm you put that cartridge in three-inch barrel s W... And shooters both time to target practice do so with standard velocity.38 Special.38! To battle gangsters with their inadequate.32 and.38 Special+P loads you care to through...